Weaning can be one of the most stressful events in a calf’s life, and how it’s handled has a big impact on animal health, growth, and long-term performance. Stress from weaning can lead to increased sickness, reduced feed intake, and lower weight gains—but with low-stress strategies, producers can ease this transition.
Here’s a breakdown of the most common weaning methods used in the beef industry, along with their pros and cons to help you choose the right fit for your operation.
1. Traditional Abrupt Separation
Description: Calves are suddenly separated from their dams with no contact afterward.
Pros:
-
Simple and fast.
-
Requires minimal equipment.
Cons:
-
Highest stress level for calves.
-
More pacing and bawling.
-
Increased risk of respiratory disease and reduced feed intake.
-
Higher treatment costs and potential weight loss.
Best for: Operations where time and labor are limited, but ideally avoided when possible due to stress impacts.
2. Fence-Line Weaning
Description: Calves and cows are separated by a strong fence but can still see, hear, and touch noses through the barrier.
Pros:
-
Calves eat more and stress less.
-
Reduced pacing and bawling.
-
Higher short-term weight gains.
-
Lower treatment rates for disease.
Cons:
-
Requires secure fencing (barbed wire, page wire, or trained electric fencing).
-
May not suit operations with limited pen or pasture options.
Best for: Producers looking for an effective, low-stress method that mimics natural weaning.
3. Two-Stage Weaning
Description:
Stage 1: Calves wear a plastic nose-paddle that prevents nursing but allows them to stay with the dam.
Stage 2: After 4–7 days, calves are separated and the nose-paddle is removed.
Pros:
-
Lowest stress method.
-
Calves vocalize and pace less.
-
Higher feed intake and better weight gains.
-
Lower disease rates.
Cons:
-
Requires extra handling twice (to insert and remove nose-paddles).
-
Nose-paddles cost.
-
More time and labor involved.
Best for: Operations that can coordinate handling events or prioritize calf health and welfare.
4. Early Weaning
Description: Calves are weaned earlier than usual—often at 3–5 months instead of 6–8.
Pros:
-
Saves forage resources during dry years.
-
Calves can be more efficient converters of feed than lactating cows.
-
Lower feed costs per pound of gain.
Cons:
-
Requires careful feeding and management.
-
Young calves are more sensitive to stress and dietary changes.
Best for: Drought years, limited forage, or operations with strong feeding programs.
Tips for Low-Stress Weaning Success
-
Move cows, not calves: Let calves stay in familiar pens or pastures whenever possible.
-
Provide feed and water early: Use creep feeding or bunk training before weaning.
-
Spread out stressful events: Don’t combine weaning with dehorning, castration, or vaccinations.
-
Practice quiet handling: Calm, patient movement through chutes or during sorting reduces stress.
-
Offer shelter: Ensure calves have access to clean, dry areas with good ventilation.
Which Method Is Best?
| Method | Stress Level | Labour | Performance | Equipment Needs |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Abrupt Separation | High | Low | Low | Basic pen setup |
| Fence-Line Weaning | Moderate-Low | Moderate | Moderate-High | Strong fencing |
| Two-Stage Weaning | Very Low | High | High | Nose-paddles, handling gear |
| Early Weaning | Moderate | Moderate | Variable | Specialized feeding program |
Final Thoughts
Weaning doesn’t have to be a battle—for you or your calves. Choosing the right weaning method based on your facilities, labor availability, and long-term goals can reduce sickness, improve performance, and even build a reputation for producing calm, healthy calves.
By investing in low-stress practices, you’re not only improving herd health and reducing treatment costs—you’re also responding to growing consumer interest in animal welfare and responsible livestock care.
